The Politically Correct Villain

Home › Forums › House of Creativity › The Writing Pad › The Politically Correct Villain

Viewing 5 posts - 31 through 35 (of 35 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #216904
    Soren_Ringh
    Participant
      0 Pirate Gold Coins

      The difference you speak of Wandering Author is the difference between a villain and an anti-hero. The anti-hero is like the villain except for one little detail. The anti-hero has some code of honor they live by that separates them from complete villainy.

      Take Dextor for instance. He is like any other serial killer, except he won’t act upon someone he considers an innocent with his murderous desires. Only those he sees as villains get the fate. If I remember right, I watched the first season when it came out, Dexter had been adopted as a small child by a cop, who recognized the cold-blooded killer within his adopted son. He was the one who gave him his code so he would be able to focus his murderous desires.

      In fact, in the first few minutes of the pilot episode Dexter had trapped another serial killer. Dexter explained that they were alike but that he didn’t kill kids.

      “Why?”, asked the doomed killer obviously confused.

      “Because I have a code.”

      I don’t know if this is in the book or not, I’ve never read it, but whether it be the book author, or the screenwriters, they were careful to show the difference between Dexter and that particular serial killer right from the start.

      I make no moral judgements here. Just an observation about the difference between an anti-hero and a true villain.

      #216905
      Wandering Author
      Participant
        0 Pirate Gold Coins
        Soren_Ringh wrote:
        The difference you speak of Wandering Author is the difference between a villain and an anti-hero. The anti-hero is like the villain except for one little detail. The anti-hero has some code of honor they live by that separates them from complete villainy.

        Take Dextor for instance. He is like any other serial killer, except he won’t act upon someone he considers an innocent with his murderous desires. Only those he sees as villains get the fate. If I remember right, I watched the first season when it came out, Dexter had been adopted as a small child by a cop, who recognized the cold-blooded killer within his adopted son. He was the one who gave him his code so he would be able to focus his murderous desires.

        In fact, in the first few minutes of the pilot episode Dexter had trapped another serial killer. Dexter explained that they were alike but that he didn’t kill kids.

        “Why?”, asked the doomed killer obviously confused.

        “Because I have a code.”

        I don’t know if this is in the book or not, I’ve never read it, but whether it be the book author, or the screenwriters, they were careful to show the difference between Dexter and that particular serial killer right from the start.

        I make no moral judgements here. Just an observation about the difference between an anti-hero and a true villain.

        As I say, I understand that. And in the book, he developed his urge to kill after an unbelievably horrific experience at a young age. (I’ve never seen the TV show; gore makes me sick.) But my point is that this choice by the author mutes the impact of the villains. Note that I didn’t say I see no difference at all – I do. If there are going to be any serial killers running around at all, I vastly prefer they stick to other serial killers. :)

        But my real point was in how it makes me see the villains. Either I conclude Dexter has a choice and could refrain from killing (in which case, his “code” would just be an excuse to seem nobler while indulging himself) – or I agree that he has no choice but to indulge his compulsion at least in limited ways. Now, if I accept that he has no choice, then I wonder about the killers he hunts. Do they have a choice? Not that I think they’re great guys even if they don’t, but it does force me to feel more sympathy for them. Not so much that I’d mind if they were arrested, or even killed in a situation where there was clearly no other choice. But enough that I feel uncomfortable with the idea of their being hunted down in that way.

        I’m not trying to say I wasn’t rooting for Dexter. I was, certainly. Of the choices available to me, he was the one to root for. But I wasn’t eager to read any more of the series, because I just wasn’t that enthusiastic about him. It wasn’t that I didn’t understand he was an anti-hero – it was the fact if he had no choice, that made me wonder about his victims. If they had no choice, shouldn’t they just get locked up where they could do no harm? (Again, I’m not taking sides on the actual debate – I’m simply examining the world of these particular stories on their own terms.) So, for me, although there was a distinction, it was a muted and uncomfortable one. Perhaps that’s even what the author was trying for. I just think we need to consider the impact of our choices. If a writer presents a story where the villain is in a sense also a victim, in that they cannot control their own urges, then I’m going to feel the resolution “should” be milder than if they show him reveling in murder for its own sake.

        Say the Dexter story I read had been rewritten, so a police officer driven to the brink by the loss of his partner hunted down the villain, shot them in a fury – then realised he’d just violated his own code. In spite of that, I’d actually feel more sympathy for that hypothetical character. Why? Although there is still the “he couldn’t help it” dynamic, he is not as similar to the person he shot. He lost his head, rather than giving in to the same urge felt by his victim. And he felt remorse afterward. Dexter hunts people who feel the same urges he does, even if he limits how he releases them. They are enough like him that – if I accept the premise he (and they) can’t help it, then I feel he should have more sympathy for them. Perhaps my reaction is unusual, but I doubt it’s unique. (I’ve got to add, even if someone who feels such urges can’t help them, that may keep me from loathing them – as I would certainly loathe anyone who chose such a “taste” – but I just can’t feel terribly warm and fuzzy toward them, either. In the book, Dexter started out by killing small animals. That’s what his adoptive father noticed. He hunted small, helpless animals. That just isn’t the sort of behaviour which makes me like someone. And, like I say, the people he hunts are a lot like him. To be sympathetic to me, he’d have to have a lot more awareness of that fact, a lot more sympathy for them. “I can’t help it, and I was lucky enough somebody else taught me to channel my urges, but you weren’t that lucky, so I’m better than you are, and I’m going to kill you” just doesn’t cut it for me. Sure, I’m a hypocrite, too – but when I catch myself at it, it makes me sick. I should at least cut people slack for the same things I expect to be cut some slack for. And I at least try to rein the hypocrisy in.)

        Again, I’m not saying you’re wrong, just that I see this from a different angle. And no matter what stories you want to write, it never hurts to know all the possible angles from which your reader may see things.

        ETA: This is forcing me to think about Dexter, and what really bothers me about him. And I realise that even if the series featured a police officer hunting down and killing serial killers because he felt they were too likely to be released and it had to be done, I’d be okay with that. There are people who really may be better off dead, in my opinion. It’s the fact Dexter likes killing. He’s too close to what he “opposes”. If his adoptive father had not desperately worked to steer him in a very specific direction, he would have been exactly like them. So that ruins the “he can’t help himself” vibe, for me at least. I can understand the father’s dilemma. I can feel real sympathy for him, even if I’m not very comfortable with his choice. But I don’t think it would be possible to ever write a story with a main character who enjoyed killing that wouldn’t leave me with a sour taste in my mouth. Did it because it needed to be done, sure. Did it and regretted it, maybe, if it were handled well. It’s that final step, the enjoyment, that is just too far for me. If you enjoy killing, then you’re just too close to the villain.

        #216908
        Soren_Ringh
        Participant
          0 Pirate Gold Coins

          I understand what your saying. I agree but as far as how the writers pulled it all off I think fascinating. As readers or viewers we’re left with choices if we continue to follow the storyline. The book sounds very similar to the show by the way. I’m guessing here, but was it in first-person?

          Take the show. Dexter has numerous voice-overs. I can understand that because if they weren’t there we wouldn’t be able to follow his thoughts. All his thoughts aren’t on his urges. Most of the time they are on concern for his sister, or an unsolved case, or why he feels so different from everybody. It all humanizes him. If we watched those same scenes without the voice overs, the effect would be greatly diminished. Most people wouldn’t be curious enough to stick around and watch it.

          He still is what he is. A serial killer but the writers have grabbed our empathy. That’s why I assume the book is written in first-person. At the very least a very close third-person. It would be very hard to grab the readers empathy otherwise. Especially in the beginning.

          If we continue to invest our time is this dark tale, we realize that it isn’t the standard good vs evil. We’re left with choices. Root for the killer who leaves the innocent be, and root for him to take down the villain who preys on the innocent. Or root for the soulless(at least that is how he or she has been portrayed) to take down the killer who unlike them, will not cross some moral boundaries. Or in this case, a strict code.

          I understand what you mean W.A. I really do. But as far as the concepts of story go. The writer kept you reading. Lets face it, a story about a serial killer being “the good guy”, is sort of messed up. Not something I’d be interested in tackling. But what does interest me is how the writers manage to hook and manipulate our emotions, and that is what writers do, to make us sympathies with such a character. Which in turn has us wondering about the hunters that he hunts.

          I remember a quote from one of the Pitch Black Vin Diesel movies. “Sometimes good cannot defeat evil. Sometimes, to defeat evil, it takes another kind of evil.”

          Or something like that :) . For storytelling purposes, how writers like “Dexter” and “Pitch Black” manage to gather readers and viewers empathy is an important lesson to learn.

          For the record, I haven’t watched any of the other seasons of Dexter. The whole rooting for the serial killer thing I find personally disturbing.

          #216574
          Soren_Ringh
          Participant
            0 Pirate Gold Coins

            Forgive the double post, but I’ve been thinking on this whole villain vs anti-hero thing here the last day and I’ve come to some conclusions on how they are used.

            First, the anti-hero would be the villain of a story if if weren’t for one little thing. That one thing is that there is somebody worse out there.

            Now were into the whole character foil thing. The term comes from the 1600’s, or something, when gems and other shiny objects were made to look more brilliant by giving them a backdrop of some foil type material. I don’t know if that’s true, but it doesn’t really matter because it does help illustrate something about character development, and particularly for this discussion, villains.

            So the anti-hero is not as bad as someone or something else within a story. I got to thinking as to how we as writers can drive this home with a good degree of success. What has been used in the different mediums for a boundary that an anti-hero shouldn’t cross when we write them, and in the case of the villain, to show that they have no issues crossing. You know what I came up with? Warning. Spoiler Alert!

            Kids…They are off-limits for an anti-hero. They can’t touch them. That act will automatically brand them as villains. There just isn’t no coming back from that one. Now if we create a villain who has no such issue hurting a kid, we not only want to see them go down, we want to see them go down screaming.

            Look at Dexter. By the way I feel it’s easiest more often to give an example through a certain well-known movie, or tv series, which has more widespread exposure than to give an example from the written medium.

            Anyway, back to Dexter. The first serial killer we see him track down we find out has killed kids. We don’t even know Dexter yet, but what we know of the other guy has sealed his fate. We sentence him to die screaming.

            Another episode I remember is where the villain transports illegal aliens into the country in containers where they are forced to try to survive in horrendous living conditions. The bad guy, and bad girl if I remember right, use these people seeking a better life for their own agendas once they have transported them in from wherever.

            This is awful of course. Something should be done about it. Human-trafficking is deplorable. Somebody should call the cops and release those poor people in the containers.

            Well Dexter doesn’t call the cops, but he does open one of the containers. We see the poor people inside. Young men and woman. Old men and woman. We also see the kids. They do this to kids?

            Die screaming.

            I remember the movie “The Brave One”, with Jodie Foster. Her character is kind of a mix of the subway vigilante and the poor woman who was attacked in Central Park years ago. After her ordeal, Foster’s character buys a gun illegally for protection. The first bad guy she kills is in self-defense. I like how the writers just didn’t shove her into the role of cold-blooded vigilante. This first killing opens the flood gates. She begins roaming the city for bad guys.

            Now doing this for a whole movie would get kind of boring. It’s like driving your vehicle 90 mph down the interstate. Pretty exciting and a little nerve-wracking at first. But a couple of hours later, that’s if we haven’t gotten cuffed-and-stuffed, it’s kind of boring. Driving 90 miles an hour has become kind of normal.

            So what do the writers do in The Brave One?

            Well Foster’s character learns of this crime lord character who her detective friend believes has killed his wife and made it look like a suicide. That is terrible, we say. This guy needs to be brought down. We want the detective to bring some justice into the world, but let’s face it. He’s bad yes, but he’s no different than the muggers and such she has been hunting on the streets. Been there-done that.

            Then we learn the second half of the story. It turns out that the murdered wife had a daughter(Oh really?). A sweet little girl who the detective believes witnessed the whole thing(The poor girl!). She is just to scared to talk about it. The murdering villain stepfather we learn will soon get custody of her(WHAT!!! :angry: ). The detective is powerless to stop him. He fears that something bad will soon happen to the little girl. Foster’s character eyes the villain with cold, hard eyes. (Sic him!)

            Die screaming you crime lording, wife murdering, planning to hurt the sweet little girl villain!

            There are many other examples of this of course, but this post is already to long. It’s interesting to me to see how something is used in a story and why it works.

            There is another no-no that shouldn’t be touched I found. I don’t believe it is as strong as threatening and abusing a child in our minds, but it is a no-no all the same.

            Don’t touch someone’s pet. Leave the crazy cat lady’s cats out of it. We don’t like people messing with our animal friends. Lizards and such not as much, not that there is anything wrong with them. They just don’t bring that cuddle factor into play. Maybe that’s a better way of putting it. Leave our darling cuddle bunnies out of it.

            We can watch or read a battle scene with nameless soldiers dying left and right and sleep like a baby. But have one of the soldiers shooting the protagonist’s faithful dog, especially if that protagonist is a child, and we really, really want to see the shooter get what’s coming to him.

            I’m signing off now. I really need to start a blog.

            #216575
            Wandering Author
            Participant
              0 Pirate Gold Coins

              I basically agree with you. (Although I seldom watch TV or movies, so in my case, examples from books or short stories would be more likely to resonate with me… ;) ) That’s one of the things that put me off Dexter – when he was younger, he killed animals. Small, helpless, innocent animals.

              For me, that line you don’t cross is in a slightly different place. You don’t kill anyone who has not done something to deserve it, “ask for it”, whatever you want to call it (that, obviously, includes kids by definition). And you don’t kill animals, especially pets or baby animals. Show me someone harming a kitten, and I will never feel the slightest sympathy for that character from that point on. Although I’m not sure it’s possible to feel more disgusted with Hitler, when I read that he used one of his own “beloved” dogs to test poison out on (was her name Blondi, or something like that?) near the end, it really drove home to me what kind of guy he was. I don’t care if he petted her first or whatever, the man killed his own dog. Okay, this is Hitler, that wasn’t all that shocking when you think of everything else he did, but it was enough to stick in my mind as the kind of act that defined him. (His expending time and resources on having his personal enemies hunted down and killed, and their deaths filmed so he could enjoy watching them, even as he dragged his country down into a disastrous defeat, was another one.) It isn’t that I think these things are worse than the wholesale murder of millions in concentration camps – obviously, they’re not. But he wasn’t standing there in the camps, watching what happened and enjoying it. He was there watching films of the executions of his enemies and enjoying that, and killing his dog – he knew those things were happening, not just in general, but in specific detail.

            Viewing 5 posts - 31 through 35 (of 35 total)
            • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.